Throughout my 20s I lived in New York and never once thought about applying to grad school. Grad school, at the time, seemed to be for people who were not really intending to become artists. I knew all the artists. I even studied with some. But the tuition–sometimes cash money, more often intangible–never passed through an institution. I paid with a loyalty that was often betrayed. But this is normal.
My real education took place in my apartment. Convinced that to be an artist I’d need lots of free time, I did occasional temp work supplemented by low-level scams and some topless dancing. This gave me lots of free time, but at the time, I didn’t know what to do with it. Sometimes I slept 12 hours a day. I remember looking in the mirror at my too-rested face and realizing the hardest thing I’d have to learn was how to make my own program, how to inhabit unstructured time without getting lost in it. I don’t know if you learn this in grad school. When, in my late 20s, I began living with a tenured professor at Columbia University the question of grad school was tabled. His grad students became my close friends. Before leaving New Zealand, in my late teens I’d unsuccessfully applied to Columbia’s graduate program in journalism. In the end, I attended the school by osmosis.
It’s only at times when I want to escape from my life that I regret not going to grad school. The bios of writers whose careers I envy usually contain the names of the prestigious MFA programs they attended. If I’d gone to grad school I’d have an agent! I would not be virtually self-published by Semiotexte, the independent press where I’m a co-editor. My writing would be reviewed in serious, adult publications. But in order for these things to happen, I would have to write different writing.
As it is, my writing is read mostly within the art world–a field in which virtually everyone attends an MFA program. And I try not to criticize this. Perhaps for the better, grad school has taken the place of my generation’s aimless experience.
I’ve noticed a trend among students in certain liberal arts undergrad schools to move to New York or Berlin or LA after Grinnell or Dartmouth or Swarthmore. Not applying to grad school is very neo-old school. And this is exciting. What will be even more exciting is if the cultural life of these cities approaches a point where alumni of less elite schools can embrace the same mixture of deep disillusion and confidence.
You can find an interview with Chris Kraus in Volume 1. of Lemon Hound.

2 comments
Chris says:
Dec 6, 2012
I can’t speak for MFAs — I am one of those weird poets who thought that a PhD in field not immediately related to trends in contemporary poetry would do more interesting things to my poetry — but it’s a common trope that if there’s one thing you learn in a standard PhD program, it’s “how to inhabit unstructured time without getting lost in it”.
Do people still move to New York or Berlin or LA to be poets? (Autocorrect suggests “ports”, which also works.) I’m sure plenty do, but I’m interested in how lots of other, smaller places are flourishing as places to go and be a poet — and I’m wondering whether you can map the choice of “going to NYC to be a poet” to “going to an MFA program to be a poet”, when there are clearly other (and possibly better, at least for some people) options.
Sina says:
Dec 8, 2012
In my twenties everyone told me I had to go live in New York, and I didn’t because I thought it was a cliche. Then I went and realized they were right. Likely not for the reasons they thought though. I moved there as soon as I could in any case but I was already in my 30s…
I think it’s important to leave the nest. Particularly the Canadian nest. It’s especially important for anyone who isn’t conventional. And I think it’s important to be where your peeps are. New York is poetry. It’s art.
The MFA is an unimaginative route and I agree, I would love to see more places that can really be alternative destinations for the proving ground that an MFA can be, but for now it seems the best option for community, discipline and growth.